Using TAFs for flight planning: alternates, fuel and change groups

Tafrob editorial team · Updated · 8 min read

Short answer

Flight planning reads the TAF for a window around the estimated time of arrival. Under FAA rule 14 CFR 91.169, an IFR alternate is needed unless forecasts show at least a 2,000 foot ceiling and 3 miles visibility from 1 hour before to 1 hour after arrival. EASA guidance for air operators adds a table saying when BECMG, TEMPO and PROB groups count.

Key points

  • Planning looks at a window, usually from 1 hour before to 1 hour after the estimated time of arrival.
  • FAA 91.169: no IFR alternate needed only if a ceiling of 2,000 feet and visibility of 3 miles are forecast for that window, with an instrument approach at the destination.
  • FAA standard alternate minima, when none are published: 600 feet and 2 miles for a precision approach, 800 feet and 2 miles for a nonprecision one.
  • FAA 91.167 links IFR fuel to the forecast: destination, alternate, then 45 minutes.
  • In the EASA table, BECMG deteriorations count from the start of the change, improvements only from its end.
  • EASA: TEMPO deteriorations from showers or thunderstorms may be ignored for planning; persistent ones such as fog may not.
Pilots in a morning preflight briefing covering the weather and the day's flight plan
Photo: U.S. Air Force 316WPA by Senior Airman Perry Aston, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Why the TAF drives the plan

A METAR says what the weather is now. A flight arrives later, so the decisions taken before departure rest on the forecast: whether the destination is usable, whether an alternate is needed, which alternate, and how much fuel to carry. The TAF is the forecast written for exactly that purpose, one aerodrome at a time, hour by hour.

The starting point in US rules is general. The Aviation Weather Handbook quotes 14 CFR 91.103: before beginning a flight, each pilot in command must become familiar with all available information concerning that flight, including weather reports and forecasts. The rules that follow turn that duty into figures. The TAF pillar page explains how to decode the report itself; this page covers how the decoded forecast is applied.

The window around arrival

Both the FAA and EASA texts read the forecast over a window, not at a single minute.

  • FAA. 14 CFR 91.169(b) looks at the period "for at least 1 hour before and for 1 hour after the estimated time of arrival".
  • EASA. AMC5 CAT.OP.MPA.182, for commercial air transport aeroplanes, lets an operator select a destination or take off alternate only when reports or forecasts show the weather at or above the landing minima "during a period commencing 1 hour before and ending 1 hour after the estimated time of arrival".

A two hour window is wide enough to absorb a late departure or a slow en route segment. It also means that a change group starting 50 minutes after the planned arrival is part of the planning picture, even if the flight expects to be on the ground by then.

FAA: the 1-2-3 alternate rule

14 CFR 91.169 lists the information an IFR flight plan must contain, including an alternate airport. Paragraph (b) gives the exception. For aircraft other than helicopters, no alternate is required if the first airport of intended landing has a standard or special instrument approach procedure, and appropriate weather reports or weather forecasts, or a combination of them, indicate:

For at least 1 hour before and for 1 hour after the estimated time of arrival, the ceiling will be at least 2,000 feet above the airport elevation and the visibility will be at least 3 statute miles.

The figures give the rule its nickname: 1 hour, 2,000 feet, 3 miles. Helicopters have a separate test in the same paragraph: at the estimated time of arrival and for 1 hour after, a ceiling of at least 1,000 feet, or 400 feet above the lowest applicable approach minima, whichever is higher, and visibility of at least 2 statute miles.

The ceiling in a TAF is the lowest broken or overcast layer, or a vertical visibility. A forecast of BKN018 anywhere in the window fails the 2,000 foot test, and so does P6SM with OVC015. Visibility in a US TAF is in statute miles; 3SM meets the test, 2SM does not.

FAA: alternate minima

Once an alternate is required, the forecast has to show it is usable. 14 CFR 91.169(c) says an airport may not be listed as an alternate unless current weather forecasts indicate that, at the estimated time of arrival there, the ceiling and visibility will be at or above the alternate minima. Those are the minima published in the instrument approach procedure. If none are published, the rule sets them:

Approach at the alternate Ceiling Visibility
Precision approach 600 feet 2 statute miles
Nonprecision approach 800 feet 2 statute miles
Helicopters, with an approach 200 feet above the approach minimum at least 1 statute mile

If the alternate has no instrument approach procedure, the forecast must allow descent from the minimum en route altitude, approach and landing under basic VFR. Note that the alternate test is at the estimated time of arrival at the alternate, not over the two hour window used for the destination.

FAA: fuel tied to the forecast

14 CFR 91.167 requires enough fuel, "considering weather reports and forecasts and weather conditions", to complete the flight to the first airport of intended landing, fly from there to the alternate, and then fly 45 minutes at normal cruising speed (30 minutes for helicopters). The alternate leg can be dropped under the same conditions as 91.169(b): an instrument approach at the destination and a forecast meeting the 1-2-3 test. A single TAF line can therefore change both the flight plan and the fuel load.

EASA: how each change group counts

The FAA texts speak of "forecasts" without naming TAF groups. The EASA guidance for commercial air transport does name them. Table 1 of AMC3 CAT.OP.MPA.182, titled "Aerodrome forecasts (TAFs) and landing forecasts (TRENDs) to be used for pre-flight planning", sets out how each part of a TAF applies to the destination, take off alternate, destination alternate and fuel en route alternate, each for the estimated time of arrival plus or minus 1 hour.

The initial part. It applies from the start of the validity period until the first FM or BECMG, or to the end of the TAF if there is none. It "should be fully applied", although it may be temporarily superseded by a TEMPO or PROB group as set out in the table.

Group Deterioration Improvement
FM and BECMG AT Applicable from the start of the change Applicable from the start of the change
BECMG, BECMG FM, BECMG TL, BECMG FM...TL Applicable from the start of the change Applicable from the end of the change
TEMPO, TEMPO FM, TEMPO FM...TL, PROB30/40 alone Transient or showery conditions (thunderstorms, showers): not applicable. Persistent conditions (haze, mist, fog, dust or sandstorm, continuous precipitation): applicable Disregarded in any case
PROB TEMPO May be disregarded Disregarded, including mean wind and gusts

The logic follows the meaning of each group. A BECMG change can happen at any time in its period, so a worsening is assumed from the earliest moment and an improvement only once it is complete. A TEMPO shower passes; fog that comes and goes can still close the aerodrome at the wrong moment. A PROB group combined with TEMPO is both unlikely and brief.

Wind. The table treats wind separately. Mean wind should be within the required limits, and gusts exceeding crosswind limits should be fully applied, for FM, BECMG and persistent TEMPO conditions. For transient TEMPO conditions, mean wind and gusts exceeding the limits may be disregarded. Note 1 of the table states that the "required limits" are those in the operator's operations manual.

Outside ICAO practice. Note 2 says that if published forecasts do not comply with ICAO Annex 3, operators should make sure guidance on applying them is provided. A US TAF with a different structure is one case where an operator's own guidance takes over.

EASA: flying without a destination alternate

AMC2 CAT.OP.MPA.182 asks for at least one destination alternate on every IFR flight, and two when the destination's weather margins or planning minima cannot be met or no meteorological information is available. It allows no destination alternate when the destination is isolated, or when the planned flight does not exceed 6 hours, two separate runways are usable, and reports or forecasts show, from 1 hour before to 1 hour after arrival, a ceiling of at least 2,000 feet or a circling based value, whichever is greater, and ground visibility of at least 5 km. The structure is close to the FAA rule, with a higher visibility in kilometres.

A worked reading

A schematic TAF, built for this page:

TAF ZZZZ 181700Z 1818/1918 24010KT 9999 SCT030
      BECMG 1819/1821 6000 BR BKN012
      TEMPO 1820/1823 3000 SHRA BKN008
      PROB30 TEMPO 1821/1824 0400 FG BKN002

The estimated time of arrival is 2130 UTC, so the window runs from 2030 to 2230 UTC.

  1. Initial part. 9999 and SCT030 apply until 1900 UTC, when the BECMG period starts.
  2. BECMG. It is a deterioration, so under the EASA table it applies from the start of the change, 1900 UTC. For the whole window the planning weather is 6000 m in mist with a broken layer at 1,200 feet.
  3. TEMPO. Showers are transient, so the 3000 m and BKN008 are not applicable to planning under the table.
  4. PROB30 TEMPO. The fog may be disregarded.

Under the EASA reading the planning values are 6000 m and a 1,200 foot ceiling, compared with the landing minima and the operator's margins. Under the FAA test the 1,200 foot ceiling fails 2,000 feet, so an alternate is required before the TEMPO or PROB groups are even considered. The comparison of TEMPO, BECMG and FM gives more examples of overlapping groups.

After departure

A plan built on a TAF is only as good as the forecast at that time. A TAF AMD issued after departure replaces the earlier forecast, and the latest METAR shows whether the forecast is on track. The TAF vs METAR page explains how to read the two together.

Method and limits

The FAA figures are quoted from the eCFR texts of 14 CFR 91.167 and 91.169, and the 91.103 duty from the Aviation Weather Handbook. The EASA table, wind rules and alternate conditions are summarised from AMC2, AMC3 and AMC5 CAT.OP.MPA.182 in AMC and GM to Part-CAT, Issue 2, Amendment 20; that guidance applies to commercial air transport aeroplanes, and the circling value in AMC2 is not reproduced because the text extraction was unclear. ETOPS rows of the table are not covered. The FAA regulation does not say how TEMPO or PROB groups count, and no FAA equivalent to the EASA table was found in the sources cited here. Part 121 and Part 135 rules, operator specific minima and national rules outside the United States and the EU were not covered. The TAF in the worked reading is a schematic, not a real forecast. This page is a reading aid, not a substitute for the regulations or an operator's manual.

Training and reference only. For flight planning, always use official briefing sources (your national weather service, AIS or approved provider).

Frequently asked questions

What is the 1-2-3 rule for IFR alternates?

It is the shorthand for 14 CFR 91.169(b). For aircraft other than helicopters, no alternate is required if the destination has a standard instrument approach and forecasts show, for at least 1 hour before and 1 hour after the estimated time of arrival, a ceiling of at least 2,000 feet and visibility of at least 3 statute miles.

Which part of the TAF matters for planning?

The periods that overlap the window around the estimated time of arrival. The FAA rule and EASA AMC5 CAT.OP.MPA.182 both use a period from 1 hour before to 1 hour after arrival. Every change group touching that window has to be read, then weighted according to the applicable rules.

Does a TEMPO group count when choosing an alternate?

Under the EASA table in AMC3 CAT.OP.MPA.182, a TEMPO deterioration tied to short lived phenomena such as showers or thunderstorms is not applicable, while one tied to persistent conditions such as fog, mist or continuous precipitation is applicable. TEMPO improvements are always disregarded. The FAA regulation does not address change groups by name.

What alternate minima apply in the United States?

14 CFR 91.169(c) applies the alternate minima published in the approach procedure. If none are published, the forecast at the estimated time of arrival must show at least 600 feet and 2 statute miles for a precision approach, or 800 feet and 2 statute miles for a nonprecision approach.

How does a TAF affect IFR fuel planning?

14 CFR 91.167 requires enough fuel, considering weather reports and forecasts, to reach the destination, then the alternate when one is required, then fly 45 minutes at normal cruising speed. Whether the alternate leg is needed depends on the same forecast conditions as 91.169(b).

Sources

  1. US Government Publishing Office, National Archives (2026). 14 CFR 91.169, IFR flight plan: Information required (eCFR)
  2. US Government Publishing Office, National Archives (2026). 14 CFR 91.167, Fuel requirements for flight in IFR conditions (eCFR)
  3. European Union Aviation Safety Agency (2022). AMC and GM to Part-CAT, Issue 2, Amendment 20 (Annex IV to ED Decision 2022/005/R), AMC2 to AMC5 CAT.OP.MPA.182
  4. Federal Aviation Administration (2024). Aviation Weather Handbook (FAA-H-8083-28A)